Why Do Some People Not Pick Up Their Dog's Poop?

Until my wife talked me out of it, I was going to call this essay A Tale of Two Shitties: because… It was the best of times. It was the worst of times. Best, because walking my dog is always top-quality thinking time. Worst, because other people walking their dogs in my neighborhood had left two poops within 100 meters of each other on the walking path.

What do people say to themselves that allows them to just watch their dog poop and then keep walking? (Other than, “no biggie, Dixon will bag it for me.”) One excuse that gets deployed in these circumstances and many other similar circumstances when people are looking to excuse their poor behavior is, “everyone does it.”

First up, No. They Don’t. Most people, I’m happy to say, pick up after their dogs. But I walk six miles a day with my beasts and a few times a week I encounter “gifts” left for me. Awww, you shouldn’t. No, really. You should not.

But it is worth examining this excuse, due to it being one that people use to explain away much that they don’t want to be introspective about.

I was at a tremendous fundraiser recently for Women’s Economic Ventures (WEV) at the great new Welcome Room space in Ventura, CA, featuring four magnificent female comedians. Tremendous laughs were had. Before the show, I was chatting with other members of the WEV Board and their partners when the subject of micro libraries came up. (Micro libraries are those cute, small, usually house-shaped setups in front yards where people offer their used books to passers-by. I think they are a wonderful idea — as is anything that promotes literacy.) The WEV CEO said she wanted to put one up in her yard as she has a massive number of books that have overwhelmed all possible places to store them in her house.

I told her that if she did, I was going to come by her house once per week and infiltrate her books with books I would source so that her neighbors would slowly get a very warped and worrying idea of who she is. I imagined books like, How to Kill, Parts 1 & 2. Stalin, Was He So Bad? Living As a Psychopath, etc. In that she knows my sense of humour well, I’m not sure that she’s still planning to have the micro library…

But I was thinking about that conversation while feeling poop-of-another-man’s-dog only a membrane of plastic bag away from my skin. Because much as I was planning to “curate” the CEO’s book offerings, so much of what we encounter in the world has been curated for us.

It can, of course, begin in our earliest years with our parents’ choices about what to expose us to. Sadly, in current times, that is very often a screen. But then at school, other people make decisions about what we must read and learn about. Also, as I’m sure you are aware, over the last decade, countless battles have been fought over the books our children are allowed to read (or not) and that their libraries are allowed to have on their shelves — shelves that mostly carried those same books for decades without demonstrable harm (and rather provable brain expansion).

Importantly, most all of these people are acting with good (ish) intention and imagine they are helping their children and yours (in one way or another). But each decision made at school about what we will not allow our kids to see means that young adults can head out into the world without ever having been constructively engaged on important subjects. Books like To Kill a Mockingbird or Adventures of Huckleberry Finn have long been used as a very tangible gateway into discussions about race and justice. If such books are removed, engagement that might lead students to seek understanding of the subject and how they might want to fit in and around it never takes place in the years when young adults are deciding who and how they want to be in the world.

Curated Reality

As these same young adults then venture beyond the classroom, this becomes very important as they will almost certainly be engaging with social media and b-level news and below, where very significant exposure curation takes place, often driven by the commercial desires of the highest bidder for your eyeballs. People who have not been taught how to analyze and critically evaluate complicated and divisive subjects are ill equipped to parse such an environment. As you may know, what you see on any such “news” site may well be different from what another person would see when visiting the very same site at the same time. What is dished up for you is decided on a very granular level based on what will most likely cause your eyeballs to linger on the site. And due to outrage and discontent being known to reliably create long linger times and increase commentary and return visits, that can guide a significant portion of what such sites select for you to view.

And it is not just the “news” or reels themselves: Facebook is well known for individualized comment ranking. This is important since what we imagine everyone “like us” is doing or accepting is much more a part of our decision-making process than many of us would like to believe.

Considering many people now have more contact with “friends” online than in real life, the ability to filter comments from those “friends” means that an algorithm is actually very involved in shaping the nature of your friendships. Friendships online tend to be much more one-dimensional than real-life friendships with all of their inconvenient complexity. When friends can be acquired and disposed of with the ease of clicks, it is tempting to ignore or dispose of anyone not in line with whatever is your hot-button tribal identity topic. You imagine you are making an evaluative decision, but the reality is, since much of your information is filtered and ranked through the platform, who you believe that person to can be manipulated by what you are offered to see of them. And so, you may make a well-thought-out decision but based on inaccurate or incomplete information — just like finding a volume of “Let’s Celebrate Hitler!” surreptitiously secreted in a nonprofit CEO’s micro library.

This is population-level mind and relationship manipulation. If Facebook and other social media algorithms are in charge of not only what you see and experience on their platform, but also your understanding of what other people “like you” think and feel and accept, then they hold great sway over a large part of how you perceive the world and the people in it. And the step from that perception to you engaging in the same activity with the understanding that “everyone like me is doing it” or “everyone like me accepts it” is a short step indeed. In fact, the behavior can even begin to seem like a proactive statement of identity. Proof of tribe.

It is additionally important to realize that no one has to actually lie to you for your perceptions to be warped. As mentioned, I walk my dogs 6 miles a day. I find a few non-picked-up poops per week. But what if my social media was sending me a picture of every unpoliced poop in town? It would look like an epidemic. Intrinsic to this is that you don’t see or register the thousands of poops that are being picked up — by far the majority. All you would see is the couple that you witness yourself and then that annoyance has the wind of a thousand other poop pics blown into its sails. And you never hear the calming, dulcet aria: Poops Picked-Up Aplenty.

This same mechanism transfers to manipulating perceptions about illegal voting. Murderous immigrants. Black criminals. Karens, Kens, etc. When all your particular feed offers is the negative and you hear nothing of the massively larger numbers of similar people not committing whatever offence — because, let’s face it, who reports on or is interested in reading about “everything is normal” — it becomes too easy to believe “everybody is doing it,” with an easily transferable target of who constitutes “everybody” and what “it” is. And once we believe that “everyone is doing it” or “everyone is OK with it,” it dangerously shifts what we believe we are reacting to and what an appropriate response is.

If we believe that others are cheating in voting, then it lowers the bar on deciding that one needs to cheat also to “make it fair.” If we believe we are looking at one criminal it generates a call to law enforcement; if we think we are witnessing a crime epidemic it can trigger a trip to the gun safe, all the while imagining that others are “good with what I’m doing.”

And such perceptions really put us all in the poop.

– Simon Dixon

Recent Essays

Bully in the Mirror

If we want our kids to bully less, we should stop denying them power. (And perhaps bully each other less also).

Continue reading

Meta-Static

The Meta settlement is not enough. It imposes restrictions around the edges, while leaving the truly damaging core functions of Facebook and Instagram: identity manipulation, continuing largely unimpeded.

Continue reading

Featured Videos

Subscribe to the Newsletter

Get the latest posts and updates delivered to your inbox.

You have successfully subscribed to The Relational Intersect's newsletter.
Something went wrong while submitting the form. Please review and try again.

Let’s chat.

Thank you for your message. Simon will get back to you shortly.
Something went wrong while submitting the form. Please review and try again.